Articles, reviews and tutorials about photography
Home About us Commercial Photography Print Gallery Articles/reviews/blog  
 Was our site of help?
Please buy though our links
Visit Keith's G+ page
Page contents

View of the blue tower, LeicesterPhoto Ninja V1.0 review

Standalone RAW processing and noise reduction software

Some time ago (actually in one of our first reviews) Keith looked at some rather clever noise reduction software for images, called Noise Ninja.

The latest software from PictureCode is also an all new RAW camera image converter, called Photo Ninja. It incorporates all the noise correction functionality of Noise Ninja.

Keith has been giving V1.0 of the software a tryout, with various RAW files from his collection.

This short review gives an overview of some of the software functionality. There is a free two week trial license available if you download the software.

The initial version of the software can work closely with Lightroom, Aperture and PhotoMechanic - plugin support for Photoshop is due with V1.1 of the software.

Supported cameras are listed in the summary below.

The functionality described below is also available for Windows PC users (system requirements)

RAW processing

If you want the best results from your camera, it's worth using the RAW camera setting, which saves files that are minimally altered data, directly from the camera sensor.

That's not to say that JPEG files from a camera won't work well for many people, just that the quality and processing options are all set in the camera at the time the JPEG file is processed.

It's not uncommon for people trying out using RAW files for the first time to be somewhat unimpressed by the image quality.

The in-camera JPEG processing is designed to give pictures with more punch and to 'look good' - that's why cameras tend to have setting for picture styles. Just remember that all these whistles and bells are turned off for RAW files.

It's this freedom to choose hoe the image is processed that gives the power and flexibility of using RAW files. You have to do some work yourself and learn the options.

digital black and white logoFYI: I've set up a LinkedIn group (~6600 members) for people interested in all aspects of Digital Black and White photography: Digital Black and White

 

installation process for Photo NinjaUsing Photo Ninja

I'm testing out the software on a Mac, but most of the screen shots would be similar on a PC.

Installation of the software (after downloading it) is pretty straightforward.

The software needs activating with a key code. Even this is made easier by the software looking at the contents of your clipboard to search for the key.

The key code arrives in an email - select the license code text , copy and then go to the software's registration screen - it will find the appropriate code and use it. No more typing long lists of characters and numbers...

This first version of Photo Ninja doesn't work as a plugin for Photoshop, so I'm testing it here as a standalone application, generating TIFF files for further processing in Photoshop. It also opens JPEG files for processing and noise reduction.

nstallation options and preferencesI don't use Lightroom or Aperture at all - Photo Ninja is more tightly integrated here.

If you do use these programs, have a look at the various examples and tutorials on the PictureCode site.

One of my quick tests of the usability of any photo software is to just fire it up and see what it does.

It opens by default in full screen mode - now personally, I tend not to like full screen applications, so I quickly had a look around the preferences and other menus to take it back to a more familiar windowed mode.

  • It's a personal preference thing, probably from using Macs with very large monitors for over 20 years.

You can also customise screen text size and overall colour schemes to your taste.

I'd just been out shooting some photos of part of a church tower (part of my specialist 'heritage architecture' work) - the important parts of these photos is the stonework - or more particularly the problems and cracks. Images are usually supplied fully rectified for use with CAD systems. However, I just wanted to see what Photo Ninja would make of some of them.

First up - browser mode.

photo Ninja browser mode

Once again, you can customise layouts for your own way of working. The large number of images above comes from shooting a scene with our GigaPan head.

It's easy to check file metadata - note that any data you amend should be entirely compatible with other applications (I only checked this with Photoshop, but it seemed fine for what I use it for).

image metadata

Opening an image gives me Photo Ninja's 'best guess' conversion of the RAW file.

You can see from the thumbnails at the bottom that it's recovered colour and detail from a very bright sky. I didn't take the shot to get a nice looking sky - look at the second thumbnail to see what I'd normally expect.

opening image in editor with corrections applied

It's important to note that this is just a default and that you can easily set your own preferences and preset options.

For a default conversion, this looks rather good, particularly when I zoom in to have a look at the detail in the stonework.

100 percent detail from raw image

custom profiling for correctionsIf you look just below the histogram, you can see that a profile for my Canon 1Ds3 camera is indicated.

One of the strengths of this software is that you can build your own profiles for light sources and camera bodies. This is in addition to the noise profiling capabilities found in the original Noise Ninja.

It's also possible to build your own lens correction profiles, covering geometrical distortions and chromatic aberrations.

I'll not cover this in this quick overview, since it's going to take quite a bit of experimentation to work out when it's going to help me.

Having a look at noise reduction performance, I went back to one of the files I used in the original review.

This was taken with a Canon 1Ds (11MP full frame) at its maximum 1250 ISO setting.

One of the real benefits of improvements in RAW processing software is that an image that was not good enough to use 10 years ago, can be reprocessed - sometimes turning a shot that would have made just an OK print into one that really works well.

Of course it helps to try and get things right in the camera (if actually possible), but in the real world that isn't always going to happen.

Move your mouse over the image below to see the default noise reduction (image viewed at 150%).

noise reduction with Photo Ninja

The neon sign is distinctly overexposed.

You can see which parts of the full image are clipping in the picture below - move your mouse over to see clipping.

image showing areas of clipping

Although I don't normally do many direct comparisons, it's worth noting that Adobe camera RAW (below) has consistently failed with the neon sign over the years. The image noise also tends to have a more 'blocky' feel to it.

ACR highlight clipping

Do test this for yourself though - select or create some tricky to process RAW files and see what you think.

My own quick tests suggest that Photo Ninja is very good at handling fine image detail, whilst the 'detail' adjustments can be used modestly without fear of noticeable halo effects (something I generally dislike).

The blue building at the top of the article, for example has a lot of tricky bright reflections which were handled very easily.

I'll finish up this overview with a few more examples, first showing processing of a rather dull underexposed shot I took from my car, when driving alongside Ulswater in the Lake District. Once again it's taken with my old 1Ds - not long after I seriously switched to digital, so still experimenting.

  • I still have, on the site, a short article I wrote about some of my initial digital experiences at the time (2004). I've left it as written and it's interesting to think that several of the issues I noted, are much more easily fixed with 2012 RAW processing software, compared to 2004.

Ulswater on a cloudy day

The original image is dark, and seriously needed white balancing (WB reading for the original 1Ds were not recorded through the lens)

Colour correction, recovery and enhancement options are comprehensive and intuitive to use.

Similarly, exposure adjustment is very effectively handled.

Move your mouse over the two images below for some of the exposure balancing adjustments.

shadow illumination

exposure offset

As the example above these two screengrabs shows, there is quite a lot you can do to even rather poor original files.

I'll close with one example of 'smart processing' - the software can analyse your images for chromatic aberration (CA) and fix it. What's more it varies the amount in different parts of the lens field of view (which can be fine tuned)

lens correction zones

This detail is from a shot taken with my old Olympus E-20 and wide angle adapter - i.e. unlikely to be in anyone's lens correction database.

Move your mouse over, to see the auto correction. For an image I've used numerous times to check CA corrections, this one impressed me.

fixing chromatic aberration

Thank you to everyone who has ever purchased something via these links. If you follow a link and then buy absolutely anything it helps me run this site (the articles are all written by myself in my spare time)
- Keith (Other ways to help the site)
Amazon UK link / Amazon France / Amazon Germany
Amazon USA link / Amazon Canada / Amazon Italy

Conclusions V1.0

There is an old adage in software development that you should avoid V1.0 products ;-)

In this case, V1.0 of Photo Ninja is surprisingly complete and usable. Since Photoshop is what's used for most of my image processing, I'll wait for V1.1 before testing it more widely.

It has however, jumped straight in as a preferred RAW processing tool for me to try with 'awkward' images.

I found some difficulties in switching between the various adjustment modes (I'm not sure of the need for the 'apply' button for each one, and the mass of options (with varying degrees of stickiness) and ability to make presets, did leave me wondering on occasions how I'd managed to process one image, and how I could do the same on another.

As someone who tends to process small numbers of images, these were minor concerns though. Where I did have a few more issues was with being able to batch process images (for stitching, for example) with identical non content-dependent settings - something I'm told is being looked at.

Documentation (on and off line) is relatively complete, but I would prefer a few more pop-up tool-tip bits of information for when I forget just what a particular slider/button does.

  • Do note that I used to do usability research for many years, so tend to spot minor niggles like this when testing software...

These are but rough edges - what really impressed me was the fundamental quality and capabilities of the RAW processing at the heart of the software.

This is definitely a bit of software that deserves to be downloaded and tested with some of your trickiest RAW files...

Discuss this review with Keith below?

Summary

Supported cameras, as of September 2012 (info from PictureCode) - Latest

Unsupported or partially supported cameras

Systems requirements
Performance issues (info from PictureCode)
  • Photo Ninja is computationally intensive and memory intensive. That said, it runs well on recent-generation dual-core processors with at least 4 Gigabytes of memory. (8 Gigabytes is recommended, particularly if you are running other applications at the same time.) On quad-core, 8-core, and 12-core machines, it will use all available cores for filter operations; the speed-up is noticeable. It will also benefit from additional RAM if you have it. A solid-state drive (SSD) can improve performance compared to a conventional hard disk


Add your comments and questions
comments powered by Disqus
The views in this article represent those of Keith Cooper.
Keith is always happy to discuss matters raised in his articles. You can Email Us Email Us
Northlight Images prides itself on its independence when giving advice. We do not sell hardware or software and have no direct commercial links with any of the software or hardware vendors that may be mentioned here. See our Review Policy for more information.

You can search all the many hundreds of articles and reviews on the site for more information

Have you found an article on the site useful or helpful?

If so, please consider sharing a link to the article or mentioning it on a forum or blog - Thanks to everyone who's helped the site become better known.

Explore our site... Digital Black and White photography and printing - some of Keiths thoughts, techniques and tips for those interested in a digital approach to black and white. There are many hundreds of entirely free articles and reviews on the site. New site content appears on the News, articles and reviews page.

Thanks to the visitors who've made Amazon purchases (any kinds of items whatosever)
via: Amazon UK/Amazon France/Amazon Germany/Amazon USA/Amazon Canada
It won't save extra money we're afraid, but it does help in the running of the site, and we really appreciate it...

Northlight Images is based in Leicester in the UK and supplies Commercial Photography services
Visiting Leicester or wondering where it is? We have views from the Leicester traffic cameras.