Contact us: +44 116 291 9092
 

A digital pinhole camera using a Canon 1Ds

  |   Article, Articles and reviews, Image Editing, Lens, photo-hacks, tutorials   |   No comment

A digital pinhole camera using a Canon 1Ds

Making your own pinhole adapters for digital SLR cameras



Tired of spending heaps of cash on your lenses? Keith describes how to make a pinhole camera out of your digital SLR.

Results are compared to a significantly more expensive lens not made of toilet paper tubes.

1ds first pinhole

Note – this article dates from 2005. I tried the ‘lens’ on my subsequent 1Ds mk3 (21MP) and as expected, the files were bigger, and that’s about it… In 2015 I’ve a 50MP 5Ds – perhaps time for another look.

Basics of the pinhole camera

The original camera — probably first noted a very long time ago when someone saw an inverted view of the world outside cast onto a wall through a hole in a window shutter.

For distant objects the optimum radius of the pinhole is approximately equal to the square root of the product of the wavelength of the light and the distance from the pinhole to the sensor.

Thus for d=50mm and a wavelength of light of 550nm we get a pinhole radius of 0.165mm or a diameter of 1/3rd mm.

For a 200mm distance to film we need a hole of 2/3rds mm.

basic geometry of a pinhole cameraBoth sizes quite easy to make, but you may need several attempts to get a good clean circular hole.

A poorly shaped hole will introduce noticeable loss of quality in the image.

For those of you wanting to delve into a bit more detail on the principles behind pinhole and pinspeck cameras, there is an excellent article at:

http://www.wesjones.com /pinhole.htm.

Basic pinhole adapter for a digital SLR

As ever, tinker with expensive cameras at your own risk!

Now comes the expensive part (apart from the ~£5000 I paid for the 1Ds body) — £3 for a replacement camera body cap.

Mk1 pinhole in plastic camera body capA small hole was made in the centre of the body cap with a scalpel blade. Not a very small hole (~0.9mm).

The picture is taken on my desk with sunlight coming in through a gap in the curtains.

You can see an image of the Sun on the desk.

The Mk1 pinhole lens.

Pinhole to focal plane is about 50mm.

Dust is always a problem with digital SLRs so a Lens Cap was made from Blu-Tack

(Info on dust and sensor cleaning)

The image quality was rather poor and blurred.

1Ds with Mk1 pinhole camera adapter

Not entirely unexpected, so I looked at a better way to get a pinhole.

A better digital pinhole SLR

By enlarging the hole in the plastic cap, you can use a better material for the pinhole.

Paper backed sticky Aluminium foil tape is very good and can easily be replaced.

Thicker foil (take-away food containers) is good but needs glueing.

Mk2 pinhole adapter

Several guides on the web suggest that very thin brass sheet is best, but there was none in the tool cupboard/kitchen.

The hole in the body cap is enlarged to about 1cm and covered with Aluminium tape.

The hole was made with a fine sewing needle.

Note the image of the Sun is dimmer than the first pinhole in the plastic.

After several tries I got a good sized pinhole and took the camera outside.

car and street - unprocessed imagecar and street after processing in Photoshop
A reduced version of the 4064×2704 image produced from a 1Ds ‘raw’ file.

1 second exposure at ISO 200 (manual setting, exposure optimised via camera histogram)

The image after a bit of processing.

Note how the original image is very soft but benefits from a bit of image processing in Photoshop

This is a sample of the original image at full resolution.

full resolution sample digital pinhole image

It shows dust on the sensor quite nicely but is not quite as good as the original 16bit uncompressed file (it’s a JPEG)

The processing steps were:

  • Convert from raw using Adobe Camera Raw (using exposure and shadows to set levels)
  • Use the Focus Magic plugin to reduce blur (Keith has written a review of Focus Magic on this site)
  • Use the Photoshop ‘Shadows and Highlights’ tool to give the picture a bit more punch.
  • Reduce the image to the size above (using the Bicubic Sharper method)
  • Convert to 8 bit mode and sRGB colour space (from Adobe 98)
  • Sharpen with Unsharp Mask for web use.
  • Save for web with no included icc profile at a medium quality setting.

50mm pinhole camera shot of ugly Ford ScorpioThe last three steps are really there to optimise the picture quality on the web (I’ve got an article discussing photos for web use elsewhere)

Excellent depth of field and no distortion.

There is so little light coming into the camera that the viewfinder is pretty useless.

It took quite a few shots to get this one of the ugly cars outside my house.

It is worth trying a number of different pinhole sizes since the increase in resolution with smaller holes is offset by diffraction effects.

Using the aluminium tape allowed several different pinholes to be pre-prepared.

The home made 200mm lens

The lens cap pinhole gives a focal length of 50mm, how about something a little longer, and zoom too?

use two slightly different toilet roll tubes to make the pinhole adapter

Two toilet paper tubes for the zoom lens.

The centre of the lens cap is cut out and glued into the second tube (hot melt glue is excellent for this)

tubes fitted togetherpainted black with red stripe
Some of the aluminium tape ensures that the end is light proofA spray of black paint inside and out keeps light reflection at a minimum and also stops dust from the cardboard rubbing off and getting into the camera.

Be sure to mask the actual camera mount from paint.

The 1Ds with its 200mm pinhole lens.

200mm EF zoom pinhole lens, EF mount, fitted on Canon 1Ds

The 200mm seemed a lot more dependent on a good quality pinhole, and also susceptible to light coming through the viewfinder.

The first attempts showed considerable vignetting, which turned out to be stray light. The 1Ds has a viewfinder shutter to stop this. You could use a black cloth if need be.

full frame unsharpened 200mm pinhole imagefull frame sharpened 200mm pinhole image
The raw images is fairly blurred as before.

13 seconds exposure at ISO 100

A sharpened version, after processing.

There was traffic at the end of the road (where the bus is in the shot below) but the long exposure loses it.

The expensive version — is it really worth it?

Well it can be…

The 1Ds with its Canon EF 70-200 2.8L IS zoom lens.

The 70-200 IS zoom from Canon costs about £1400 more than the other lens

The street taken with a 70-200 lens. inset shows full resolution detailNote that since I mostly use this lens hand held, its tripod mount has been removed.

If you need sharper pictures, faster f-ratios and a slightly more ‘Pro’ look.

Inset is a detail at full resolution showing the increase in resolution that you get for around £1400.

(Note that this image is a medium res JPEG file)

This lens and the 16-35mm 2.8L are my most used lenses.

The image stabilisation feature lets me regularly take shots hand-held at 1/50th sec.

The moon is about half a degree across and is a critical test of any lens, particularly against a dark sky.

The moon taken with a 1Ds and 70-200mm lensThe moon, taken with a Canon 1Ds and 200mm pinhole camera adapter
The moon – Canon lens

Inset shows full frame.

The Moon – Keith’s much cheaper lens

Both images sharpened

I’ve a good example of the quality of this lens in part two of my article looking at the DXO Pro raw conversion and lens correction software (off-axis detail)

Conclusions

I was very surprised at the quality I got out of the 50mm version after a bit of image processing. The Focus Magic plugin worked wonders and I discovered that the Photoshop ‘Shadows and Highlights’ tool can make appreciable differences to soft images even when set at 1% for the shadows.

The smaller pinhole of the 50mm version seems to produce pictures that are easier to process for sharp results. This may be due to the amount of blur just being too much to easily correct from the larger 200mm pinhole, or it could be that the larger hole was not so good quality as the smaller one.

The pinhole lens is certainly lighter to carry around, although the need for a tripod and 15 second exposures might affect its usefulness in some areas (wildlife/photojournalism).

I’m not sure if I’d have got better results painting the outside of the 200mm pinhole adapter white like the 70-200, but I’m sure the red stripe helped a bit… :-)

Just because I do photography for a living doesn’t mean it can’t still be fun!

More experimental and How-to articles

All articles and reviews are listed on our main Articles and Reviews page, or use the search box at the top of any page. Experimental items, hacks and how-to articles are all listed in the Photo-hacks category Some specific articles that may be of interest:

  • Using old lenses on your DSLR
  • The 1Ds digital pinhole SLR camera A Canon 1Ds pinhole camera, making a 50mm 'standard' pinhole and a 200mm zoom version - results are compared to a lens some £1400 more expensive.
  • Canon View Camera An adapter ($20) to use an old MPP 5x4 view camera with a Canon 1Ds. Article shows details of construction and just what it can be used for. Could be adapted for any DSLR and many old large format cameras.

 


Buying anything from Amazon (not just what's listed) via any of the links below helps Keith and Karen keep the site going - thanks if you do! [Amazon UK]