1Ds3/7D quick detail check
How sharp are the images from the Canon EOS 7D? I believe there has been some discussion on the matter ;-)
It was suggested (thanks) I take some shots at f/6.3 with the 7D and 1Ds3.
Taking both cameras outside, I picked one of my sharper lenses…
Here are some 100% crops, processed in ACR with no sharpening
Taken with a TS-E90 lens of the view outside of my house, cable release, manually focused with LV x10 ISO100 AV mode
… and the 7D
Then I magnified the 1Ds3 image (PS Bicubic smoother) to match the scale of the 7D image.
Of course normally you need to apply some sharpening to any RAW image.
and finally the scaled 1Ds3 image, sharpened
Just a quick test, but it confirms what I’d expect – the 7D sensor out-resolves the 1Ds3 sensor with the same lens, it just includes less of the scene.
I’ve made no attempt at optimal sharpening of any image, but it’s enough to show (to my own satisfaction) that the 7D 18MP crop frame sensor out-resolves the full frame 1Ds3 21MP sensor with a good lens at f/6.3.
When you consider that the equivalent full frame sensor at 7D density is ~45MP, I’m not exactly astounded at the results :-) Another way of looking at it is that the 1Ds3 is equivalent to under 9MP at 1.6 crop.
Of course this completely ignores the field of view difference. If I used two good lenses at the appropriate focal lengths to match fields of view, then I’d expect the 21MP sensor to provide more detail than the 18MP one. Once you start comparing this though, you are changing a lot more variables…
Note that I’m using the centre of the frame of a good sharp lens – that old kit zoom you saved from the 300D might not be nearly as good as you thought.
As ever YMMV, but I’ve no problem with 7D image sharpness…
All the latest articles and photo news items appear on Keith's Photo blog .
We've a whole section of the site devoted to Digital Black and White photography and printing. It covers all the specialist articles and reviews written by Keith Cooper.
Buying anything from Amazon (not just what's listed) via any of the links below helps Keith and Karen keep the site going - thanks if you do! [Amazon UK]